When it comes to pizza, everyone has their favorites! We reached out to local parents to discover their preferred pizza spots in the DMV area, and the responses were plentiful. Below, you will find some of the top suggestions along with what makes these places special.
Piccoli Piatti Bethesda (Two Locations)
Piccoli Piatti stands out as a beloved neighborhood eatery, known for its delightful, walk-in only policy. With a maximum wait time of just 20 minutes, you can usually find a table without hassle. Their menu features authentic Italian fare and Neapolitan pizzas, all at reasonable prices. The crust is airy and chewy, the tomato sauce is crafted from genuine San Marzano tomatoes, and the fresh mozzarella is both rich and gooey. Unlike many Italian eateries that focus on over-the-top Americanized dishes, Piccoli Piatti embodies the essence of straightforward, high-quality Italian cuisine in a family-friendly setting. — Clau Johnson, North Bethesda
Andy’s Pizza (14 Locations in the DMV)
For those yearning for that genuine New York-style pizza experience, Andy’s Pizza is a must-visit. The crust strikes a perfect harmony between thin, crispy, and chewy, topped with just the right amount of sauce and ingredients. As someone who grew up in Philadelphia, where local pizza spots are ubiquitous, I can vouch for the fact that the best pizzas come from NY/NJ/PA. Whenever I need a taste of authentic New York pizza, Andy’s is my top choice. — Radhika Prout, Germantown
Coal Fire Pizza Frederick, Gaithersburg
What I adore about Coal Fire is their signature sauce, which expertly combines sweetness with a hint of spice. The crust, perfectly charred, pairs beautifully with the sauce, creating a unique flavor experience all its own. While it may not resemble typical New York-style pizza, it offers a delightful alternative. — Sunita Shukla, Rockville
The Stained Glass Pub in Silver Spring
Having enjoyed pizza at The Stained Glass Pub for many years, it has become a cherished spot for numerous locals. They feature half-price pizza nights on Mondays and Tuesdays, friendly staff, and a lively atmosphere at the bar. It’s also where I met my former spouse, making it all the more special! — Mary Halako Dunton, Silver Spring
Paisano’s (36 Locations Across the DMV)
Paisano’s is a family favorite due to their extensive selection of pizza toppings and the freshness of their ingredients. The option to choose different types of crusts is an added bonus. Everything tastes incredibly fresh, and their Rockville location actively supports our small community pool and local elementary school. Not to mention, their non-pizza menu items are equally impressive! — Jen Sorrentino, Rockville
Potomac Pizza (Chevy Chase, College Park, Rockville, Potomac)
As a proud native of Cleveland, I’m quite discerning when it comes to pizza… but I must say, Potomac Pizza has won me over. Initially, I hesitated to give it a try, assuming it would be overrated and pretentious. However, after a 10-year-old student of mine raved about it, I decided to check it out. Now, it’s my go-to spot for takeout. The Potomac Village location has a nostalgic vibe reminiscent of the 90s, and the pizza is genuinely delicious. — Brittany Higdon, Bethesda
For Katie Schubert, the best pizza experience happened at Savelli’s Pizza during a family trip to Colorado Springs, CO, in the summer of 1997. Her favorite toppings? Extra cheese and sausage!
Disclaimer
The content presented here serves as general information and reflects the perspectives of local parents. Individual experiences and preferences may vary, and no guarantees regarding specific outcomes or satisfaction levels are implied. Each dining experience is subjective, influenced by personal tastes and circumstances.
